`base64-url` below 2.0 allocates uninitialized Buffers when number is passed in input
High
Vulnerability Details
I would like to report an uninitialized Buffer allocation issue in `base64-url`.
It allows to extract sensitive data from uninitialized memory or to cause a DoS by passing in a large number, in setups where typed user input can be passed (e.g. from JSON).
# Module
**module name:** `base64-url`
**version:** 1.3.3
**npm page:** `https://www.npmjs.com/package/base64-url`
## Module Description
> Base64 encode, decode, escape and unescape for URL applications.
## Module Stats
48 047 downloads in the last day
311 047 downloads in the last week
1 374 420 downloads in the last month
# Vulnerability
## Vulnerability Description
The problem arises when a number is passed in, e.g. from user-submitted JSON-encoded data.
The API should not propagate the already-bad Buffer issue further.
On Node.js 6.x and below, this exposes uninitialized memory, which could contain sensitive data.
This can be also used to cause a DoS on any Node.js version by consuming the memory when large numbers are passed on input.
## Steps To Reproduce:
`console.log(require('base64-url').encode(1000))` (Node.js 6.x and lower — note uninitialized memory in output)
`require('base64-url').encode(1e8)` (any Node.js verision — note memory usage and time)
## Supporting Material/References:
- OS: Arch Linux current
- Node.js 6.13.0
- Node.js 9.5.0
# Wrap up
- I contacted the maintainer to let them know: Y
- I opened an issue in the related repository: N
I contacted the author on 2017-03-02.
I did not receive a reply, but on 2017-08-17 a semver-major version 2.0.0 was released with a fix.
I want a CVE assigned to this issue, also I would prefer the fix to be backported to 1.x branch — a lot of modules still depend 1.x as of 2018-02-26.
Top-10 apps `@latest` versions of which install affected `base64-url@1` through their deps chains:
```
664945 react-native
346288 metro-bundler
83764 hubot
81089 sails
51724 phonegap
45522 csrf-tokens
28326 hubot-mock-adapter
25778 mock-hubot
23712 connect-phonegap
18808 nodedata
```
In total, there are about 2460 such apps in the npm registry, to my knowledge.
## Impact
Sensitive uninitialized memory exposure on Node.js 6.x or lower
Denail of Service on any Node.js version
Actions
View on HackerOneReport Stats
- Report ID: 321692
- State: Closed
- Substate: resolved
- Upvotes: 5